THE LAST POINT: ​Nothing worse than what might have been!

​John Maher of Salthill-Knocknacarra battles St Brigid's Bobby Nugent during last Sunday's AIB Connacht GAA SFC Club semi-final match at ECC Pearse Stadium Picture: Piaras Ó Mídheach Sportsfileplaceholder image
​John Maher of Salthill-Knocknacarra battles St Brigid's Bobby Nugent during last Sunday's AIB Connacht GAA SFC Club semi-final match at ECC Pearse Stadium Picture: Piaras Ó Mídheach Sportsfile | sf

THE LAST POINT

What might have been? Is there any phrase more beloved of fans and equally hated by sports people than the plaintive query ‘what might have been?’, a refrain that is getting a fair outing these days as the stakes rise higher and higher as the sporting year draws to a close. Those four simple words evoke a sense of loss, wonder, despair, regret and, for a sports person, can be among the most destructive to their pysche but the phrase is almost impossible to ignore.

​Clare’s Inagh-Kilnamona and Roscommon’s St Brigid’s are two of the most recent and high profile victims of ‘what might have been’ curse as both clubs saw their dreams of provincial glory shattered in the most gutting of circumstances, Thurles Sarsfields landing a match winning point in added time of extra-time last Sunday in Zimmer Biomet Páirc Chiosóg Ennis while the Kiltoom club saw an ill-timed gust of wind literally blow their defence of the Connacht Club Championship off-course, a blocked shot in the follow-up only adding to the heartbreak in ECC Pearse Stadium.

As a neutral, you couldn’t have asked for a better spectacle, TG4’s cameras beaming pictures all over the world that captured the essence of the inches between ecstasy and despair; the delight in the Salthill and Thurles camps contrasting ever so sharply with the sight of Brigid’s and Inagh Kilnamona players slumping to the ground or just plain flat-out collapsing, the one point margin at the end making it even more galling.

Those two clubs are just the latest to suffer the ‘what if’ curse – Ballinamore Sean O’Heslins, defeated by Salthill Knocknacarra just a week previously, know how St Brigid’s feel to a certain extent. It wasn’t quite the same thing, the Galway team always had that bit extra but in coming so close and feeling it could have been closer makes watching Salthill’s victory hurt that little bit more. Theoretically, Salthill advancing to the Connacht Final against Castlebar Mitchells should be a boost to the Leitrim champions but it doesn’t quite work out like that – intellectually, Ballinamore players should take pride from pushing the Galway lads so hard but, watching the wild celebrations in ECC Pearse Stadium, it must feel downright impossible to draw any comfort from it.

Just ask Fenagh St Caillins! I imagine Ballinamore’s neighbours know instinctually that a good performance from the Leitrim champions in Connacht reflects well on the county and on them as finalists but, deep down in their gut, seeing Sean O’Heslins do battle against Salthill must have felt like a kick in the guts – that could, maybe even should, have been us! And it must be impossible not to relive a thousand and one other small moments, be it refereeing decisions, missed chances, dropped balls and any one of a myriad of tiny events that combine in the course of a sporting event.

Kiltubrid know the feeling too after the Junior A Final and I’m sure seeing Aughnasheelin head off to Hastings Insurance Mac Hale Park this Saturday to take on Mayo’s Ardagh in the Connacht Club Intermediate Semi-Final will only deepen the gloom around the parish – hard to avoid feelings of what might have been when the next door neighbours are embarking on a glorious adventure.

I write this not to inflict casual cruelty on the footballers of Fenagh St Caillins nor Kiltubrid but it highlights the challenge that both clubs face going into 2027. I can’t count the amount of times I’ve been told since those County Finals that those defeats were the end for both clubs, that Fenagh and Kiltubrid won’t win their respective titles next year or maybe ever, a stark judgment that doesn’t sit too easily with this writer because, for a moment of time, both teams were well on their way to victory.

The challenge for both clubs and indeed for any sports person trying to pick up the pieces after a defeat is not in burying the memories deep down, nor it is in painfully analysing every detail, every slip or moment that contributed to the defeat – it is a cliche, a true one nevertheless but the night is darkest before the dawn and as cruel as losing a big game can be, the motivation gained from it, utilised correctly, can drive a sports person to new and unheard of heights.

The challenge for both clubs and indeed for any sports person trying to pick up the pieces after a defeat is not in burying the memories deep down, nor it is in painfully analysing every detail, every slip or moment that contributed to the defeat – it is a cliche, a true one nevertheless but the night is darkest before the dawn and as cruel as losing a big game can be, the motivation gained from it, utilised correctly, can drive a sports person to new and unheard of heights​​​​​​​​

Think I’m raving? Maybe I am but I remember a conversation in Pairc Sean Mac Diarmada all the way back in 2014. Aughawillan had just stunned defending champions St Mary’s Kiltoghert to land the Fenagh Cup and after interviews and photos, I found myself chatting with Declan Darcy and, being the Dub fan that I am, talk turned to Dublin’s defeat at the hands of Jim McGuinness earlier in the year. It was a devastating defeat for Jim Gavin’s, one that heralded a new era of massed defences and safety first football and, at that point, nobody was certain the capital boys could bounce back from the trauma.

But to quote Yoda, “The greatest teacher, failure is” seems to be borne out by the Dubs’ reaction to that defeat, Declan revealing that anger was boiling through the squad; the anger not at losing, but at their failure to perform, to react or anticipate what Jim McGuinness’ warriors might do, the former Leitrim captain quipping that the players were almost knocking down the door to get back on the training field! The hunger and determination not to get caught again drove the Dubs to six All-Irelands in a row, statistically the greatest team of all time, and at its core of it all was the hurt inflicted on them by Donegal.

It helps when your team is stacked with players like Fenton, Connolly, McCarthy, Mannion, O’Callaghan, Cluxton, Brogan, McCaffrey and so many others but the key lesson remains the same, be it losing a Connacht Club match or a County Final – can you absorb the lessons of a heart-breaking defeat without letting it inhibit you? Can the hurt drive you to greater heights without crippling you emotionally, leaving you vulnerable the next time the pressure is on? We have psychologists, lifestyle coaches and wellness experts in almost every aspects of life nowadays, not just sport, but the fundamental question is can a team ignore what might have been and aim for what could be in the future?

Powered by
Register
Follow us
© 2026 Formpress Publishing LTD. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice